Waterproof costume makeup crayons are not all equally resistant to sweat, rain, or smudging, so check the product’s stated wear and removal guidance before choosing. My best overall pick is Blue Squid Face and Body Paint Crayons, 12 Colors, a practical middle ground for shoppers who want a focused set without an oversized assortment. For more color variety, Mr. Pen Kids Face Paint Sticks, 36 Colors offers a broader palette, while Dress Up America Face Paint Crayon Kit, 6 Colors keeps the choice simple for a small project. The main tradeoffs are color count, stick size, ease of application, and how readily the paint washes off—water resistance and easy cleanup can pull in opposite directions. Read on for the full breakdown and guidance on choosing for your event, wearer, and desired finish.
Get beauty and skincare favorites delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The 12-color Blue Squid set is the roundup’s best overall balance: it avoids the limits of a tiny palette without asking buyers to manage a large collection.
- Mr. Pen’s 36 colors and Blue Squid’s 84-piece set prioritize variety; they suit group activities or detailed designs better than a one-look costume.
- Jumbo and XL formats favor broad coverage, while smaller sets and slimmer sticks are easier to store and manage for simple face details.
- Washable labeling points toward easier cleanup, not dependable water resistance; buyers should verify wear claims and removal instructions separately.
- The Dress Up America six-color kit and the Halloween special-effects kit serve different jobs: one keeps color choices compact, while the other is the more specialized route for effects-focused looks.
| Mr. Pen Kids Face Paint Sticks, 36 Colors |  | Best for Color Variety | Quantity: 36 face paint crayons | Application: Face painting | Texture: Smooth | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Drawdart Face Painting Kit for Kids and Adults, 12 Jumbo Washable Face and Body Paint Crayons |  | Best for Easy, Water-Free Application | Quantity: 12 crayons | Length: 5.1 inches each | Colors: 12 vibrant colors | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Blue Squid Face and Body Paint Crayons for Kids, 84-Piece Set |  | Best for Large Groups and Color Range | Quantity: 84 crayons (2 sets of 42) | Crayon length: 3.25 inches | Colors: Classic and metallic | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Blue Squid Face Paint Crayons for Kids, 18 XL Washable and Non-Toxic Body Paint Sticks |  | Best for Guided Costume Ideas | Quantity: 18 crayons | Length: 3.25 inches each | Formula: Non-toxic, washable, hypoallergenic, paraben-free, fragrance-free | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Washable Face Paint Crayons for Kids, 18-Piece Set |  | Best for Ingredient-Conscious Buyers | Pieces: 18 | Crayon length: 3.25 inches | Formula: Water-based, hypoallergenic, non-toxic, paraben-free, fragrance-free, vegan | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| JOYIN Face and Body Paint Crayons, 24-Count Set |  | Best for Color Variety | Brand: JOYIN | Set size: 24 crayons | Crayon length: 3 inches each | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Beesjuy 12-Color Washable Face and Body Paint Kit for Kids |  | Best for Easy Cleanup | Colors: 12 | Format: Paint pencils | Base: Water-based | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Dress Up America Face Paint Crayon Kit, 6 Colors |  | Best for Simple Costume Looks | Brand: Dress Up America | Product type: Face paint crayons | Set size: 6 pieces | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Halloween Face Paint Markers, 18 Colors |  | Best for Water-Resistant Performance Looks | Colors: 18 total: 12 matte, 4 UV, and 2 metallic | Application: Face and body | Pigment: Water-resistant and sweat-resistant | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Blue Squid Face Paint Crayons, 12 Colors |  | Best for Sensitive-Skin-Conscious Families | Brand: Blue Squid | Quantity: 12 crayons | Colors: Black, dark blue, light blue, gold, green, orange, pink, purple, red, silver, white, and yellow | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Spooktacular Creations Halloween Special Effects Makeup Kit |  | Best for Special-Effects Looks | Face paint crayons: 5 | Paint sticks: 2 | Application sponges: 3 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Dress Up America Face Paint Crayons, 12 Colors with Artbook |  | Best for Guided Costume Designs | Brand: Dress Up America | Product type: Face paint crayons | Colors: 12: red, yellow, blue, light blue, green, mint, black, white, orange, violet, brown, and pink | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| BOBISUKA Water-Based Face and Body Paint Sticks, 12 Colors |  | Best for Brush-Free Application | Brand: BOBISUKA | Product type: Face and body paint sticks | Colors: 12 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| waterproof costume makeup crayon | Colors | Removal |
|---|---|---|
| Mr. Pen Kids Face Paint Sticks | — | — |
| Drawdart Face Painting Kit for | 12 vibrant colors | — |
| Blue Squid Face and Body Paint | Classic and metallic | Makeup remover or soapy washcloth |
| Blue Squid Face Paint Crayons | — | — |
| Washable Face Paint Crayons fo | — | Makeup remover or mild soap and water |
| JOYIN Face and Body Paint Cray | — | Makeup remover, cleanser, or soap |
| Beesjuy 12-Color Washable Face | 12 | — |
| Dress Up America Face Paint Cr | Red, yellow, blue, green, black, and white | Soap and warm water |
| Halloween Face Paint Markers | 18 total: 12 matte, 4 UV, and 2 metallic | Makeup remover or wipes |
| Blue Squid Face Paint Crayons | Black, dark blue, light blue, gold, green, orange, pink, purple, red, silver, white, and yellow | Wipe off with a damp cloth |
| Spooktacular Creations Hallowe | — | Soap and warm water or makeup remover |
| Dress Up America Face Paint Cr | 12: red, yellow, blue, light blue, green, mint, black, white, orange, violet, brown, and pink | — |
| BOBISUKA Water-Based Face and | 12 | Wipes off with a damp cloth |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Mr. Pen Kids Face Paint Sticks, 36 Colors
Thirty-six colors give this set the broadest stated palette among these five, making it a flexible choice for group costumes or designs that need several shades. Compared with the Blue Squid 18 XL set, Mr. Pen offers twice as many colors, though the listing does not provide the same detail about fragrance-free ingredients or removal with makeup remover. The smooth texture is described as giving even coverage, and the washable formula favors easier cleanup over longer-lasting waterproof wear. That distinction matters: this roundup is about waterproof costume crayons, but water resistance is not specified here. I’d choose it for variety and straightforward washable use, not for a look that must hold up through sweat or wet weather.
Pros:- 36 colors support more varied designs than the 18-color options in this batch
- Smooth application is described as providing even coverage
- Washable formula supports simpler cleanup
- Listed for use by children and adults
Cons:- Waterproof performance is not specified
- The product information does not detail ingredients or a specific removal method
Best for: Families or costume groups who want many color choices for varied face-paint designs and prefer a washable formula.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need confirmed waterproof wear or detailed ingredient claims, since neither is provided in the product information.
- Quantity:36 face paint crayons
- Application:Face painting
- Texture:Smooth
- Coverage:Even coverage described
- Cleanup:Washable
- Suitable for:Children and adults
Our verdict“Choose Mr. Pen for a wide color selection and washable convenience, but pick a product with an explicit waterproof claim if staying power is your priority.”
Drawdart Face Painting Kit for Kids and Adults, 12 Jumbo Washable Face and Body Paint Crayons
Jumbo, 5.1-inch crayons are the practical distinction here: they offer a larger grip and apply without water, which can simplify quick costume touch-ups at a party or school event. Unlike the Blue Squid 84-Piece Set, Drawdart keeps the selection to 12 colors, so it is easier to keep the kit focused but offers less range for elaborate designs. Its water-based formula is described as hypoallergenic, non-toxic, paraben-free, and vegan, and the crayons wash off with mild soap and water. The tradeoff for that easy removal is that waterproof wear is not claimed; the listing also gives no verified coverage or wear-time details. I’d favor it for convenient application and cleanup rather than costumes that need to endure moisture.
Pros:- 12 jumbo crayons measure 5.1 inches each
- Applies without water
- Formula is described as hypoallergenic, non-toxic, paraben-free, and vegan
- Washes off with mild soap and water
Cons:- Waterproof performance is not specified
- 12 colors offer less variety than the 36- and 84-crayon sets
- Coverage and wear-time claims are not independently verified in the supplied product information
Best for: Parents and event organizers who want larger, twist-up crayons for fast face and body painting without water.
Not ideal for: Costume wearers seeking confirmed waterproof makeup or a broad palette for detailed designs.
- Quantity:12 crayons
- Length:5.1 inches each
- Colors:12 vibrant colors
- Formula:Water-based
- Formula features:Hypoallergenic, non-toxic, paraben-free, vegan
- Application:Twist-up crayons; applies without water
- Cleanup:Mild soap and water
Our verdict“Pick Drawdart for larger, water-free crayons and easy washing, not for a costume that needs proven waterproof staying power.”
Blue Squid Face and Body Paint Crayons for Kids, 84-Piece Set
84 crayons across classic and metallic colors make this the largest set in the group, useful when several people need makeup or a costume design calls for more than basic shades. Its description explicitly calls the formula waterproof, a closer match for this roundup’s focus than the washable-only claims for Mr. Pen or Drawdart. That staying-power angle comes with a cleanup tradeoff: removal may call for makeup remover or a soapy washcloth rather than a quick rinse. Each crayon is 3.25 inches long, shorter than Drawdart’s 5.1-inch jumbo sticks, and the 84 pieces are supplied as two sets of 42. The formula is described as fragrance-free and suitable for sensitive skin, but those claims are listing information, not independent verification.
Pros:- 84 crayons include classic and metallic colors
- Product description explicitly states that the formula is waterproof
- Fragrance-free, paraben-free, and described as hypoallergenic
- Suitable for face and body painting
Cons:- Removal may require makeup remover or a soapy washcloth
- At 3.25 inches, crayons are shorter than Drawdart’s jumbo crayons
- Skin-suitability and waterproof claims are supplied by the product listing
Best for: Costume groups, performers, or families who need a large range of classic and metallic shades and want an explicit waterproof claim.
Not ideal for: Buyers who prioritize the simplest possible cleanup or prefer fewer crayons to store and organize.
- Quantity:84 crayons (2 sets of 42)
- Crayon length:3.25 inches
- Colors:Classic and metallic
- Formula:Non-toxic, hypoallergenic, paraben-free, fragrance-free
- Water resistance:Described as waterproof
- Removal:Makeup remover or soapy washcloth
- Intended use:Face and body painting
Our verdict“Choose Blue Squid for the widest stated selection and explicit waterproof positioning, provided you are comfortable with more involved removal.”
Blue Squid Face Paint Crayons for Kids, 18 XL Washable and Non-Toxic Body Paint Sticks
18 crayons plus an online face-painting ideas guide give this Blue Squid set a more approachable starting point than its own 84-piece counterpart. The smaller palette is easier to manage for a few costume looks, while the guide can help users who need design inspiration. Its 3.25-inch crayons are shorter than Drawdart’s 5.1-inch jumbo sticks, and the listing describes a washable formula rather than making an explicit waterproof claim. Cleanup is listed as makeup remover or a soapy washcloth, so “washable” does not necessarily mean an instant rinse. Fragrance-free and paraben-free ingredients are also described, but the listing supplies those claims rather than independent verification. I’d choose this set for a manageable kit and ideas, not for maximum color range or proven water resistance.
Pros:- 18 crayons offer a more manageable selection than the 84-piece set
- Includes access to an online face-painting ideas guide
- Formula is described as washable, fragrance-free, and paraben-free
- Designed for face and body painting
Cons:- Waterproof performance is not explicitly stated
- Removal may require makeup remover or a soapy washcloth
- Skin-safety claims come from the product listing
Best for: Parents or first-time face painters who want a modest color selection and an included source of design ideas for school events or costumes.
Not ideal for: Performers needing a confirmed waterproof formula, or groups wanting the much larger selection in the Blue Squid 84-Piece Set.
- Quantity:18 crayons
- Length:3.25 inches each
- Formula:Non-toxic, washable, hypoallergenic, paraben-free, fragrance-free
- Use:Face and body painting
- Cleanup:Makeup remover or soapy washcloth
- Included bonus:Online face-painting ideas guide
Our verdict“Choose this Blue Squid set for a guided, mid-size kit, but not when explicit waterproof wear or the widest palette matters most.”
Washable Face Paint Crayons for Kids, 18-Piece Set
Water-based, vegan, fragrance-free, and paraben-free are the clearest points of difference for buyers comparing formula claims. Like the Blue Squid 18 XL set, this kit has 18 crayons and offers removal with makeup remover or soap and water; unlike that Blue Squid option, its listing does not identify the colors included or provide an ideas guide. The product description says the set supplies makeup for 100+ faces, but that coverage statement is a listing claim, not a standardized measure. These are washable crayons, not a confirmed waterproof pick, so I would not rely on them for a wet-weather costume or long event without more wear information. They suit creative activities where gentle-sounding formula details and straightforward removal matter more than verified staying power.
Pros:- Water-based formula is described as hypoallergenic, non-toxic, and vegan
- Fragrance-free and paraben-free formula claims
- Removal options include makeup remover or mild soap and water
- Listed for parties, school events, cosplay, and other creative activities
Cons:- Waterproof performance is not specified
- The included colors are not identified in the product information
- The stated coverage for 100+ faces is a product-description claim
Best for: Families seeking an 18-piece set with stated vegan and fragrance-free formula features for parties, cosplay, and creative activities.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a known color palette, an included design guide, or an explicit waterproof claim.
- Pieces:18
- Crayon length:3.25 inches
- Formula:Water-based, hypoallergenic, non-toxic, paraben-free, fragrance-free, vegan
- Removal:Makeup remover or mild soap and water
- Coverage:Product description states enough makeup for 100+ faces
- Suggested activities:Parties, school events, cosplay, and creative activities
Our verdict“Choose this set for its stated vegan, fragrance-free formula and easy-removal options, but skip it if waterproof wear or color details are must-haves.”
JOYIN Face and Body Paint Crayons, 24-Count Set
For costume looks that call for plenty of color choices, this 24-crayon set offers more range than the six-color Dress Up America kit, including 18 classic and 6 metallic shades. The large, 3-inch crayons suit bold face and body designs at parties or Halloween events, and the oil-based formula can help keep pigment from rinsing away with water alone. That water resistance comes with a cleanup tradeoff: you’ll need makeup remover, cleanser, or soap rather than a quick rinse. The crayons are described as non-toxic and compliant with US toy standards, with sensitive skin listed as the intended skin type, but the product data does not give wear-time details. I’d choose JOYIN for color variety, not for easy removal or a confirmed all-day waterproof finish.
Pros:- Offers 24 crayons, including six metallic colors.
- Three-inch crayons provide a substantial format for face and body designs.
- Crayon application is straightforward for costume makeup.
- Described as non-toxic and compliant with US toy standards.
Cons:- Oil-based paint does not come off with water alone.
- No specific wear-time or waterproof-duration claim is provided.
Best for: Parents and costume groups who want classic and metallic shades for a range of party or Halloween designs.
Not ideal for: Anyone who needs quick, water-only cleanup or verified waterproof wear-time information.
- Brand:JOYIN
- Set size:24 crayons
- Crayon length:3 inches each
- Color mix:18 classic and 6 metallic
- Formula:Oil-based
- Safety:Non-toxic; meets US toy standard
- Listed skin type:Sensitive
- Removal:Makeup remover, cleanser, or soap
Our verdict“Choose JOYIN when metallic options and a broad color selection matter more than fast, water-only cleanup.”
Beesjuy 12-Color Washable Face and Body Paint Kit for Kids
Beesjuy is the cleanup-first choice in this group, not the strongest match for buyers who specifically need waterproof costume makeup. Its water-based paint pencils are described as washable with soap or lukewarm water, a much easier removal route than JOYIN’s oil-based crayons, which call for cleanser or makeup remover. Twelve colors give kids room for recognizable costume designs, though this set does not list metallic or UV shades like the Halloween Face Paint Markers. The washable formula may be a poor fit for sweaty performances or long events where resistance to water matters. The seller recommends an allergy test before use, and the product information does not detail wear time. I’d pick it for supervised activities where straightforward cleanup matters more than staying power.
Pros:- Includes 12 colors for a range of simple designs.
- Paint pencils can be used on both face and body.
- Described as washable with soap or lukewarm water.
- Water-based format favors easier cleanup than JOYIN’s oil-based crayons.
Cons:- Washability makes it a weaker choice for water-resistant wear.
- An allergy test is recommended before use.
- No wear-time details or specialty metallic and UV colors are listed.
Best for: Caregivers planning short costume activities or parties who want face and body paint that washes off with soap or lukewarm water.
Not ideal for: Performers or costume wearers needing water-resistant makeup to hold up through sweat or prolonged wear.
- Colors:12
- Format:Paint pencils
- Base:Water-based
- Use:Face and body painting
- Cleanup:Soap or lukewarm water
- Skin guidance:Seller recommends an allergy test before use
Our verdict“Choose Beesjuy for kids’ face and body designs when easy washing matters more than water resistance.”
Dress Up America Face Paint Crayon Kit, 6 Colors
Dress Up America keeps the choice uncomplicated: six familiar colors—red, yellow, blue, green, black, and white—in a crayon format for quick costume accents and pretend play. It is easier to approach than the 18-color Halloween Face Paint Markers if you only need basic shades, but it gives up the markers’ matte, UV, and metallic options. The sticks are described as easy to apply and removable with soap and warm water, so this is not the set I’d choose when water resistance is the priority. The product makes a long-wearing claim, but no specific wear-time details are supplied. Its compact color selection suits simple designs; buyers planning detailed or multicolor body art may find the JOYIN 24-count set more flexible.
Pros:- Includes six useful basic costume colors.
- Stick format is described as easy to apply.
- Designed to wash off with soap and warm water.
- Suitable for costumes, parties, and pretend play.
Cons:- Only six colors, fewer than the JOYIN and Halloween marker sets.
- Soap-and-water removal is not a water-resistance feature.
- No specific wear-time information is provided.
Best for: Families seeking a small set of basic colors for quick costume details, parties, and imaginative play.
Not ideal for: Wearers who need water-resistant makeup, specialty shades, or enough colors for elaborate designs.
- Brand:Dress Up America
- Product type:Face paint crayons
- Set size:6 pieces
- Colors:Red, yellow, blue, green, black, and white
- Form:Stick
- Container:Plastic
- Listed skin type:All
- Model number:935
- Removal:Soap and warm water
Our verdict“Pick Dress Up America for simple, easy-to-remove costume accents rather than water-resistant or highly detailed makeup.”
Halloween Face Paint Markers, 18 Colors
Among these five options, the Halloween Face Paint Markers make the clearest stated case for water- and sweat-resistant pigment, which gives them a stronger performance focus than washable Beesjuy or soap-removable Dress Up America. The 18-color set mixes 12 matte, 4 UV, and 2 metallic shades, while its ink supports thick and thin strokes for broader fills or finer costume details. The marker format differs from the crayon-style JOYIN and Blue Squid sets, so buyers specifically seeking crayons may prefer those instead. Resistance also means cleanup takes more than a rinse: the product calls for makeup remover or wipes. A patch test is recommended because skin types vary, and the provided details do not state how long the pigment resists water or sweat.
Pros:- Pigment is described as water-resistant and sweat-resistant.
- Combines matte, UV, and metallic colors in one set.
- Marker ink supports both thick and thin strokes.
- Made for face and body painting for kids and adults.
Cons:- Requires makeup remover or wipes for removal.
- A patch test is recommended because skin types vary.
- No duration is given for water or sweat resistance.
Best for: Kids and adults creating party or performance looks who value stated sweat and water resistance plus UV and metallic color options.
Not ideal for: Anyone who wants crayon application, water-only removal, or a clearly specified resistance duration.
- Colors:18 total: 12 matte, 4 UV, and 2 metallic
- Application:Face and body
- Pigment:Water-resistant and sweat-resistant
- Stroke options:Thick and thin strokes
- Removal:Makeup remover or wipes
- Age range:Kids and adults
- Skin guidance:Patch test recommended
Our verdict“Choose these markers for water-resistant performance-style designs if marker application and remover-based cleanup suit you.”
Blue Squid Face Paint Crayons, 12 Colors
Blue Squid stands out for its stated water-based, non-toxic, vegan, hypoallergenic, and paraben-free formula, paired with 12 twist-up crayons that apply directly without water. The 5.5-inch sticks are longer than JOYIN’s 3-inch crayons, and the twist mechanism offers a ready-to-apply format for face, body, and hair. That convenience does not make it the most water-resistant option: the product says to wipe it off with a damp cloth, unlike the Halloween Face Paint Markers’ stated water- and sweat-resistant pigment. The color range includes gold and silver, but there is no wear-time claim in the supplied details. A patch test is still advised, so the sensitive-skin positioning is not a substitute for checking individual reactions.
Pros:- Includes 12 colors, with gold and silver among the shades.
- Twist-up crayons apply directly without water.
- Can be used on face, body, and hair.
- Described as water-based, non-toxic, vegan, hypoallergenic, and paraben-free.
Cons:- Damp-cloth removal suggests it is not intended to resist water.
- A skin patch test is advised despite the sensitive-skin-oriented claims.
- No wear-time or waterproof-duration details are provided.
Best for: Families seeking a long-format, directly applied crayon set for face, body, and hair, with ingredient claims aimed at sensitive-skin-conscious buyers.
Not ideal for: Anyone prioritizing confirmed water or sweat resistance, or who needs a stated long-wear duration.
- Brand:Blue Squid
- Quantity:12 crayons
- Colors:Black, dark blue, light blue, gold, green, orange, pink, purple, red, silver, white, and yellow
- Length:5.5 inches
- Formula:Water-based, non-toxic, vegan, hypoallergenic, and paraben-free
- Use:Face, body, and hair
- Application:Twist-up; apply directly
- Removal:Wipe off with a damp cloth
- Skin guidance:Patch test advised
Our verdict“Choose Blue Squid for convenient, directly applied crayons and ingredient-focused claims, not for a verified waterproof finish.”
Spooktacular Creations Halloween Special Effects Makeup Kit
I’d choose this kit for costume designs that need more than colored lines: it pairs five face paint crayons and two paint sticks with scar wax, a spatula, and three sponges. That gives a beginner several ways to build character details and simulated wounds without assembling tools separately. Compared with Dress Up America Face Paint Crayons, 12 Colors with Artbook, it trades a larger stated color selection and step-by-step guide for sculpting materials and application tools. The listed makeup is water-based and designed to come off with soap and warm water or makeup remover, but the supplied details do not claim water resistance. I’d skip it for a look that must hold up through rain, sweat, or splashing; its strongest case is variety of effects, not waterproof wear.
Pros:- Combines crayons and paint sticks with application tools and scar wax
- Scar wax and spatula support sculpted wound effects
- Three sponges offer additional ways to apply makeup
- Water-based makeup is designed to wash off with soap and warm water or makeup remover
Cons:- No water-resistance claim is provided, so it is a weak match for the waterproof roundup promise
- The supplied product details do not state the crayons’ color count or wear performance
- Offers fewer listed crayons than Dress Up America’s 12-color set
Best for: Cosplay and Halloween makers who want crayons, sponges, and scar wax in one kit for character makeup and simulated wounds.
Not ideal for: Anyone who needs makeup explicitly rated as water resistant or wants a clearly documented range of crayon colors and wear performance.
- Face paint crayons:5
- Paint sticks:2
- Application sponges:3
- Scar wax:1
- Spatula:1
- Intended use:Halloween, cosplay, theater, and special effects makeup
- Makeup base:Water-based
- Removal:Soap and warm water or makeup remover
Our verdict“Pick this kit for varied Halloween and cosplay effects, but not when waterproof wear is the priority.”
Dress Up America Face Paint Crayons, 12 Colors with Artbook
The main advantage here is 12 named colors plus an artbook that can help newcomers turn a costume idea into a finished face design. A hard plastic case also keeps the short, 2 1/4-inch crayons together between parties. Compared with BOBISUKA Water-Based Face and Body Paint Sticks, 12 Colors, this set adds printed guidance and a protective case, while BOBISUKA highlights a non-slip grip and direct application. The deciding drawback is clear: this product is not water resistant, so I wouldn’t choose it for wet weather, heavy sweating, or a look that needs to last through splashes. It is better suited to supervised, short-term costume play where convenient cleanup matters more than staying power.
Pros:- Includes 12 colors for varied face and body designs
- Step-by-step artbook gives beginners design guidance
- Hard plastic case helps keep crayons organized
- Non-toxic, skin-safe ingredients and soap-and-water cleanup are specified
Cons:- Explicitly not water resistant
- Short 2 1/4-inch crayons may be less convenient for larger designs than longer sticks
- The supplied details do not give wear-time or application performance information
Best for: Parents and beginner costume painters who want a broad color selection, a storage case, and design guidance for parties or creative play.
Not ideal for: Wearers expecting makeup to resist water, sweat, or splashes, or anyone seeking a long-wear costume finish.
- Brand:Dress Up America
- Product type:Face paint crayons
- Colors:12: red, yellow, blue, light blue, green, mint, black, white, orange, violet, brown, and pink
- Crayon length:2 1/4 inches
- Included:Artbook and hard plastic storage case
- Ingredients:Non-toxic, skin-safe
- Cleanup:Washes off with soap and warm water
- Water resistance:Not water resistant
- Model number:936
Our verdict“Choose this for guided, washable costume painting and organized storage, not for water-resistant wear.”
BOBISUKA Water-Based Face and Body Paint Sticks, 12 Colors
For quick costume designs without a brush or water cup, I’d favor these 12 direct-apply paint sticks. The non-slip grip is a practical touch for drawing details, while the colors can be used directly or mixed for more variation. Compared with Dress Up America Face Paint Crayons, 12 Colors with Artbook, BOBISUKA focuses on straightforward handling rather than a guidebook and storage case; both are water-based options, and neither is water resistant. The damp-cloth removal may suit quick cleanup, but it also reinforces that this is not a pick for a look that must withstand rain or sweat. Patch testing is recommended, so I’d be cautious for sensitive skin and follow that advice before a full-face design.
Pros:- 12 colors can be used directly or mixed
- Applies without brushes or water
- Non-slip grip supports controlled handling
- Damp-cloth cleanup is convenient for quick removal
Cons:- Explicitly not water resistant
- Patch testing is recommended before use
- No artbook or application tools are listed
Best for: Costume painters who want 12 brush-free face and body colors they can apply directly and wipe away with a damp cloth.
Not ideal for: Anyone needing water-resistant makeup, or buyers who prefer a kit with a design guide, included application tools, or no patch-test recommendation.
- Brand:BOBISUKA
- Product type:Face and body paint sticks
- Colors:12
- Item form:Stick
- Weight:205 g
- Skin type:All
- Water resistance:Not water resistant
- Removal:Wipes off with a damp cloth
- Warranty:3 years
Our verdict“Choose BOBISUKA for convenient brush-free costume painting, provided water resistance is not a requirement.”
How We Picked
I compared the 13 listed options through the needs implied by waterproof costume makeup crayons: usable color selection, stick format, likely control for face and body designs, portability, cleanup claims, and suitability for different wearer groups. A waterproof claim matters only when the manufacturer states the conditions and removal method, so I treated washable language as a separate attribute rather than proof of water resistance. Product names and listed formats support comparison of assortment size and intended use, but they do not establish wear time, skin compatibility, or performance in rain.
The ranking favors options that appear to balance practical color choice and everyday costume use, then gives specialized roles to broad palettes, jumbo sticks, compact kits, and effects-oriented products. I place larger assortments higher for group use or creative range, not because more colors automatically mean better wear. Since the provided product details do not verify waterproof testing, I avoid presenting any item as guaranteed waterproof; buyers should confirm labeling, patch-test guidance, and removal instructions before applying makeup.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Waterproof Costume Makeup Crayons
Choosing a crayon set is about matching the format and claims to the occasion, not simply picking the biggest palette. These checks can help separate a convenient washable craft-style set from makeup suited to a long costume event.
Check What “Waterproof” Actually Means
The word waterproof can describe resistance to a splash, sweat, or longer exposure, and those are very different expectations. Look for explicit wear conditions and directions rather than treating “water-resistant,” “long-wearing,” and “washable” as interchangeable. Washable often signals easier removal with water or cleanser, which may be useful for children but can conflict with staying put through perspiration. For an outdoor event, check whether the maker describes sweat or rain resistance and how the product should be removed afterward. If no clear claim or instructions are provided, plan for touch-ups and avoid relying on the crayon for prolonged wet conditions.
Match Palette Size to the Design
A large set such as the 36- or 84-piece options can help when several people need different colors or a look uses many shades. For one character design, a 6- or 12-color set may be quicker to organize and less likely to leave unused sticks behind. Buyers often mistake a high color count for better coverage; color quantity says little about pigment strength or how smoothly a stick applies. Make a short list of the colors your design needs before choosing. If the set lacks a key shade, layering or mixing may take more time than choosing a different palette.
Choose Stick Size for Control or Coverage
Jumbo and XL crayons make broader marks faster, which can help with body paint or larger areas. Their wider tips may be less precise for fine outlines, small symbols, or around facial features. Slimmer formats generally offer more control, though they can take longer to cover a large design. A common mismatch is buying a large stick for detailed face art simply because it seems easier to grip. Think about the design’s smallest lines as well as its largest colored areas, and consider whether a brush or sponge is needed for the finish you want.
Factor in Skin Sensitivity and Safe Use
“Non-toxic” does not mean that every wearer will tolerate a cosmetic product, and a children’s label is not a substitute for checking the ingredient and use information. Review the manufacturer’s age guidance, intended application areas, and any warnings before opening the set. A small patch test ahead of an event can reveal irritation before a full costume look is applied. Avoid applying crayons to broken or irritated skin, and take extra care around eyes and lips unless the directions specifically allow those areas. For shared group use, clean hands and avoid passing a used stick directly from one face to another.
Plan for Cleanup Before the Event
Easy cleanup can matter as much as wear, especially when makeup is applied to children or clothing may be nearby. Read the removal directions and check whether the product calls for water, soap, or another cleanser; “washable” does not guarantee effortless removal from every surface. Test a small amount on an inconspicuous area of fabric if costume staining would be a problem. Do not scrub sensitive skin aggressively when pigment remains; follow the maker’s instructions and allow time for gentle removal. For an event with limited access to a sink, pack wipes or the recommended cleanser rather than assuming the crayon will rinse away on the spot.
Decide Whether Portability or Variety Matters More
Large multi-piece kits can support group activities, but they need more storage space and make it easier to misplace colors. Compact six- or 12-color sets are simpler to carry for a single costume or a quick touch-up. Before choosing a big assortment, check whether the listed piece count refers to distinct colors, multiple sticks, or included extras. An artbook or effects components can add useful direction for a beginner, but may be unnecessary if the goal is basic face accents. Choose the smallest set that covers the planned designs unless sharing or experimentation is part of the event.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I assume a washable face paint crayon will also stay on in rain?
No. Washable and water-resistant describe different priorities: washable suggests removal is manageable, while water resistance refers to how the paint holds up against moisture. The product name or color count cannot confirm performance in rain or sweat. Check the maker’s specific wear claims and removal instructions before using it outdoors. If the claim is unclear, plan for a sheltered setting or bring a backup rather than relying on it to last through wet weather.
Which set makes the most sense for painting several people?
A broader assortment, such as the Mr. Pen 36-color set or Blue Squid 84-piece set, gives a group more shades to share. The tradeoff is extra sorting and storage, and a higher piece count does not confirm that every person will get an individually suitable product. Check what the count represents and follow hygiene directions when sharing makeup. If everyone needs only a few basic colors, a smaller set may be easier to manage and reduce leftovers.
Are jumbo face paint crayons better for a child’s first costume design?
Jumbo sticks can be easier to grip and cover larger areas quickly, which may help with simple designs. They are less suited to narrow lines and fine details than a smaller tip. For a beginner, a compact palette with a few needed colors can also reduce the chance of a child becoming overwhelmed by choices. Consider the child’s age, the design, and the maker’s use guidance rather than choosing by stick size alone. An adult should supervise application, particularly near eyes.
Should I choose the largest color set for the best value?
Not automatically. A large palette is useful when several people need different shades or the design calls for many colors, but unused sticks add clutter rather than practical value. A smaller set, such as a six- or 12-color option, may be a better fit for one costume and easier to carry. Compare the listed pieces with the number of colors and included extras, then match the palette to your actual design. Also check application and cleanup directions; a large assortment cannot compensate for an unsuitable wear claim.
What should I do if the product listing does not explain water resistance or removal?
Treat the claim as unverified and look for the manufacturer’s package information or instructions before use. Do not infer waterproof performance from terms such as washable, non-toxic, or face and body paint. If the details remain unclear, choose a product with explicit guidance for the conditions you expect, or plan a look that can tolerate touch-ups. Follow age and skin-use directions, and patch-test ahead of the event. Keep the recommended removal method available so cleanup does not become a last-minute problem.
Conclusion
For most shoppers, Blue Squid Face Paint Crayons, 12 Colors is my best overall choice because its focused palette makes sense for a typical costume without the scale of a group kit. Mr. Pen’s 36-color set is my best value for buyers who need variety across multiple designs, while Blue Squid’s 84-piece set is the best premium-style pick for broad group use and creative range. Beginners may prefer the Dress Up America six-color kit for a simpler starting palette; buyers seeking larger, faster strokes can look at the jumbo or XL sets. For effects-focused costumes, the Spooktacular Creations special-effects kit is the specific-use option. None of the listed names alone verifies waterproof performance, so I would confirm the maker’s wear claims and removal directions before choosing any crayon for rain or heavy perspiration.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
